Monday, 11 May 2015

Poem in Interfaith Dialogue in Indonesia: A Brief Review of Ulil's Easter Poem

Poem as an art form is very powerful to deliver ideas and convince people. Its intriguing chosen words, beautifully framed lines and deeply thought reflection are some main attraction points of a poem. Thus, a poem may tickle mind, as well as grab heart. In fact, poem is often used either intentionally or unintentionally to contribute to social change expected. In the interfaith dialogue context, it is no exception.
 
 While interfaith dialogue advocates may use poem to deliver her/his aspirations, some philosophers, religious figures, spiritualists have been using poems to reflect on their conviction and/or inner journey. Even, as a matter of fact, several (parts) of holy scriptures of different faiths are written in poetic styles, resembling a poem. It is a personal deepest struggle and search toward life, love, human, nature and even the Supreme Being that spur the expression through a poem. Thus, frequently a poem is more a personal one, rather that being used to aim collective groups. Nevertheless, a poem, later, may be used for advocacy by the writer her/himself or others.
One of an interesting poem that is about interfaith issue is written by an Indonesian Muslim scholar, Ulil Abshar Abdalla. His personal background is undoubtedly strong Islam tradition. His thoughts on religions are seen very progressive and liberal,1 that invites support and admiration as well as opposition and criticism. I would like to introduce one of his poems written about Easter and Jesus.2


Easter Poem

By Ulil Abshar-Abdalla

He who collapsed,
on the holy virgin’s lap,
resurrected after three days, against death.
He who was weak,
revived an impossible expectation.
He who is the weakest,
His body bears our sufferings.
***************************
He who is the weakest,
His suffering conquers kings of the world.
He who falled in love with morning,
after being stoned painfully.
He who looked up to the holy sky,
swathed in scarlet red cloth: Love me, please!
****************************************
They argue
about who died on the wooden cross.
I’m not interested in the debate of theologians.
It is the pouring blood which strongly touches me.
When I boast my faith,
The painful body lying on that wood,
keeps reminding me:
In fact, He also suffers, with the insulted.
************************************
My Mohammed, your Jesus, your Buddha, your Krisna, your Confucius,
they all are my teachers,
who teach me about the vastness of the world, and love.
*************************************************
Your disease, O believers:
You easily become complacent, arrogant,
boasting yourself like a peacock.
You are eager to judge!
*********************
The body with the pouring blood on that wood,
is not a peacock.
He teaches us, about love,
for those who are misled and insulted.
**********************************
Suffering sometimes teaches you
about a humble faith.
The letters in the scriptures,
often make you feel you are the only holiest person.
**********************************************
Yes, your Jesus is also my Jesus,
He has saved me from a faith,
which is arrogant and too proud.
He makes me love the insulted!
****************************
(Translated by S.Belen)

This poem is powerful, because not only is written by non-Christian, but also brings the humane side as well as the understanding of different perspective. The suffering of Jesus as believed by Christian is vividly and emotionally described, as if a Christian is reflecting on the Easter meaning. Yet, Ulil connects it with his identity or belief as a Muslim. Yet, he expands to other (figures) of faith and tries to find the common ground for all. Humility and love are some of them, while at the same he criticises act of arrogance and proud. Thus, it is definitely a result of a deep process of an interfaith dialogue, a true passover. Yet, whether this poem is effective or not, it is quite difficult to say. Whereas many people enjoy and possibly get some enlightenment, some become more defensive and reject it totally. The poem itself once went viral in the internet in Indonesia. It usually goes viral again during Easter period. Nevertheless, a poem indeed is a refined form of human expression, that often gives softer but sharper approach to an issue. This poem, then, I will say is pretty valuable.

1 He is also known for his activism in a group called “Liberal Islam Network.”

Tuesday, 5 May 2015

Malala Gives Me Hope

Nobel Peace Prize winner Malala Yousafzai's work is not unknown to the world. She stands out as an inspiration to deprived, oppressed and marginalized populations with her sheer grit, determination and guts demonstrated by her in the wake of an attack on her by the Pakistani Taliban because she was defying their diktat of disallowing girls from the Swat valley in Pakistan to attend school. The youngest winner of the Nobel Peace Prize, Malala bravely survived a horrendous and brutal attack to continue with her relentless advocacy for empowering young girls through the medium of education. My interface with her work began when I was gifted her autobiography (I am Malala: The Girl Who Stood Up for Education and was Shot by the Taliban (Weidenfeld & Nicolson, 2013) by my brother.
http://www.womensweb.in/2015/02/malalas-autobiography-book-review/. It proved to be an inspiring read. It also sent shivers down my spine as I read about her and her father's struggle to educate young boys and girls in Pakistan and the opposition that they encountered in their endeavours. This line of hers remains etched in my mind and over time me and my family have come to admire this young and little but gutsy and spirited lady from Pakistan - "One Child, One Teacher, One Pen And One Book Can Change The World". 

In Nepal last year, for SIT's (School of International Training) CONTACT South Asia program, I heard Malala speak from the platform of the Nobel Peace Prize ceremony. Once again she inspired me with her very articulate ideas about how education can transform the world. It was a delightful moment for Indians and Pakistanis sharing the forum to hear to Kailash Satyarthi, an Indian and Malala, a Pakistani share the Nobel peace prize together. This came as an affirmation of the fact that if these two enemy countries joined hands, they could conquer the world. The purpose that drove Satyarthi and Malala was also very similar ... upliftment and betterment of children, the hope for this world.

And then to give me more inspiration, came a song on Malala which got me glued the very first time I listened to it on YouTube. The song is titled "Malala gives me Hope" and is a tribute by a music band in Pakistan 'Laal' to the courage shown by Malala. This song for me gives the perfect message of peace and combines the power of music and feminism to effectively demonstrate what one young lady full of courage can do to change this world in her own way. Just listen to this song and you will know about Malala's story, how she faced the extremist elements of Taliban, how she continued to fight for the girl child's rights despite the threats to her life and the way she came to be known as Pakistan's brave voice who did not fear those who were manipulating religion to meet their selfish ends. The song is spirited, full of beats, amazing lyrics which convey the essence of Malala's struggle and its impact in Pakistan and has the right, upbeat mood to make you listen to it again and again. Once I'd heard this song, I just could not stop listening to it because to me it was a wonderful and brilliantly done job of using music as a tool to communicate change and peace. Music and words associated with it can be a tool for social change and the song by Laal just proves this right. It is a significant way of conducting advocacy over an issue. The song was recorded in English and that remains my only grouse, Because the song should reach all corners of Pakistan and South Asia, and English is a language that most are not familiar with in the sub-continent. So, recording the song in various native languages like Hindi, Urdu, Punjabi, Sindhi can be helpful. Albeit, the song successfully weaves in a narrative of Malala's life story and this is the message that should reach out to audiences. The song was released in 2013 and features lead guitarist and vocalist Taimur Rahman and Haider Rahman on flute (http://tribune.com.pk/story/578644/malala-inspires-documentary-song-at-home-and-abroad/). It is gratifying to hear this song because it is just near to perfect in symbolizing Malala's struggle and rightly creates an atmosphere that denounces war and extremism. It has a story like feel to it. It gives hope and does not shy away of directly confronting issues that face Pakistan in modern times. 

Sample these lines 

Well the Taliban they run the country
From the north of Wazirstan
They make a few of their people happy
They don't care about the rest of them

They have supporter in higher places
Who turn their heads to the city sun
And they given them the fancy money
To tempt anyone who come

In its praise of Malala, the song also exposes the various issues that plague Pakistan and how the government in that country is turning a blind eye to these. In such a despondent scenario, there is still hope, as the song conveys, in the form of Malala who is the shining light for Pakistan and its young men and women. The ultimate form of 'hope' is Malala because she dared to raise her voice against those who were hell bent upon denying rights and freedom to young girls in Pakistan, therefore, robbing Pakistan of its bright future. The theme of hope runs through the song and through the last lines this hope for peace is kept alive when the singer hums -


Can't you see that the tide is turning
Don't make me wait till the morning comes 

Music in any language can be the most impactful medium of promoting peace because music has a universal language ... a language that nobody really knows yet understands. Music remains an ageless, timeless and immortal medium that people can easily connect with and relate to. I have realized this repeatedly, especially when I listen to musicians like Yanni who with their soulful music have managed to sway audiences irrespective of gender, nationality and religion. The power that music possesses can comfortably transcend man made barriers. Even as an Indian, listening to this song filled me with a feeling of peace, tranquility and inspiration, even making me dance to its tune. It filled me with more pride and respect for Malala and her mission. Truly music can connect even enemies and bring them to the same page. I am sure, after listening to this song you all will share my thoughts on the power of music to promote peace. 

Saturday, 2 May 2015

Gus Dur and His Jokes

A person's story that has inspired me is Gus Dur's story. Gus Dur, who is also known as KH Abdurrahman Wahid, is a great Muslim leader of Indonesia. He comes from a strong Islam tradition. His grandfather is the founder of Nahdlatul Ulama, the biggest Muslim organization in Indonesia. His father is also a great ulema, who once became a minister of religion. Gus Dur himself underwent intensive religious education in Indonesia and abroad. Later, he held the highest executive leadership position at the organization, his grandfather founded. During a political transition, after Suharto regime's downfall, Gus Dur was successfully elected as the president of Republic Indonesia. Despite of all his successes, he faced several bitter failures, including being dethroned from his president position in 2001. He was also considered being too controversial. His controversy often raised strong resistance from religious groups. He was marked as being liberal. Yet, he argues that his stand is actually a representation of “friendly Islam, not angry Islam” (in Indonesian: “Islam yang ramah, bukan yang marah”). Even, he is a fervent supporter to protect minority rights. This idea is shown in many actions and statements he made. Interestingly, he used many jokes to tell a message. Some of them are following.

---
At the gate of heaven, there was a debate among three religious leaders and an angel who guards the gate. Those three religious leaders, a monk, an imam and a pastor, thought oneself should have entered heaven first, as their service and piety during their life. Suddenly, a young guy who looks dirty and smelly came. The angel checked its book for a while, and then let the young guy enter. Surely, those three religious leaders protested harshly against this unfair treatment.
“Who was he?” asked the monk.
“He was a public bus driver?” answered the angel.
“A driver? So what has he done?” asked the pastor.
“He often drove carelessly because he got drunk.”
“Oh unbelievable! He often got drunk and he gets privilege to enter heaven, even earlier than us?!”
the imam and the other two were extremely upset.
“You should understand. Because of him, many people who rode with him, pray to God so sincerely. At the same time, many people got so sleepy while you deliver your sermon that even they do not pray anymore.” the angel explained.


---
“Which religious believer is the closest to God?” asked Gus Dur.
“Hindu people, they are pretty close to God. They say “Ohm”1 to open their prayer. Christian even is much closer to God. They call God “Father”.”
“Then, do you know who is the furthest?”
“Muslim.”
“They need a loudspeaker to call God.”2

While I am fully aware that not everyone will support or agree with such kind of humor, I still see those humorous stories told by Gus Dur powerful. They indeed influence my perspective and impressions not only about Gus Dur and Muslim, but also about human, society, life and even God. Gus Dur, as a religious leader, civil society leader, and state leader, has eloquently mastered skills to tell jokes and stories. Therefore he is considered as an influential figure by many in Indonesia (He also gets acknowledgment and high appreciation from international public). The stories may be (a bit) sarcastic. Yet, as Oscar Wilde said, “Sarcasm is the lowest form of wit, but the highest form of intelligence.”


1
A similar pronunciation, “Om” in Indonesia is a common word used to call “Uncle.” It actually comes from the Dutch word, which has the same meaning.

2 In Indonesia, almost every mosque is equipped with loudspeaker that can make call for prayer (adhan) or prayer be heard to as many people as possible outside the mosque building. 3 In fact, some religious groups were offended.

Monday, 27 April 2015

The road less traveled

I have never shared this story. That is why it becomes important to tell it now. I experience no hesitation in recounting this very personal account to a bunch of supposed strangers because all of you in Team Hope, by now, for me, are close friends. In fact, it is like a catharsis of emotions for me since this story lies deep inside me for a long time. This is my story! And this is my sister's story. My sister is special for me. And many have asked why? Because sisters are always special! Mine is more special because she has been an adopted child for my parents. Our bond may not be a real bond in the sense of being of the same blood, but it is a bond that I will cherish and preserve for times to come.

My Family
The story is thus ... I must have been in Class 7 or 8 when my mother expressed her desire to adopt a girl child. She had this desire for having a second child but somehow this was left unfulfilled. She wanted to adopt a girl. For someone, as young as I was in that age, this was shocking. I could not fathom why my mother wanted to do so. She had me and I had her. I had always been a single child, had enjoyed the privileges and attentions of being one. I was extremely uncomfortable to the idea of sharing my own space, my belongings, and most importantly my parents' love with an outsider, a stranger. She was not one of my own. How on earth could I accept her? I remember turning extremely defiant and not supporting my mother in her decision. I knew she would be hurt. But then I had become selfish for I could not imagine this intrusion in a life that had been so fulfilling and well-guarded. I kept thinking about how I would face my friends, how life would change, how would I face my friends. What would I tell them? That she is my sister and what would they think about a sister suddenly cropping up for me when they all knew I was the only child. I reclined into a self-created space of denial, insecurity, jealousy and my mother was well aware of this. Today, when I think about all of this, I am pained at the fact that I hurt her so much. But then I was myself a child then, bereft of an understanding of complicated issues like bringing an adopted girl child into one's home.

Gradually, I gave in! Sort of succumbed and surrendered to the wishes of my other. I welcomed this shy, little, reclusive and soft girl called Rohini into our home. Initially, it was a bit difficult to adjust to the presence of another person in my life. Little things that ideally should not have mattered started affecting me ... like sharing space, things and most importantly the love of my parents, for whom I was the center of attraction till she came. With time, I began to enjoy Rohini's presence which made me feel like I now had the sister I always wanted. I began spending more time with her, talking to her and she also started to open up. She came from a troubled and deprived background and craved for love. I could sense that she was happy to be with us even though she spoke really less. She still is a lady of few words. In all these years, she has grown to be my best friend. I care for her like any sister would and today we can talk for hours together, we rely on each other and share every little secret. We are like partners in crime! I have seen her transform from a shy, silent, introvert person to a confident, outspoken, brave young girl whom I feel proud to call my sister. There are many who express surprise when they learn that we are not real sisters. To them, I say, she is a special child for the family. She brought to us what money, luxury and comforts of all manner could not have brought. She brought for us profound gratitude, love, warmth, care, affection and the feeling of belonging. Only a special person can do this. One who is God's most loved child. She is indeed and I keep telling her that she is special to me. The two of us standing together, it will be difficult for anyone to make out that we are not real siblings. But it can't be as real as this ... our bond will only get closer and stronger.

The time when my parents decided to go ahead with this unconventional decision to this day when I see a smile on their faces when they see us together, I realize that it must have been equally difficult for them to face constant questions from family, society, relatives, acquaintances with regard to the step that they took. There must have been people who would have strongly advised them against this step, a few must have discouraged. They also must have faced taunts about wanting to adopt a girl child and not a boy. I cannot stretch my imagination as to how, given the time and the traditional set up that they came from, they took this bold step because it is what their heart told them to follow. How difficult would it have been for them to convince me, to answer my questions, to overcome the guilt that I put them through, even so unknowingly. It must have been a tough call. Yet, today they stand out as winners, as proud parents of two daughters. In the process, they never burdened either me or my sister with their expectations, while giving complete freedom to us to travel the path we chose for ourselves. They stand besides us in thick and thin, and somewhere, even as a married woman now, I know they will stand by me whenever I call out to them. To me, theirs is a story of inspiration for they took the road less traveled.


Sunday, 26 April 2015

Nationalism and Extreme Patriotism: A Threat to Global Peace


"Nationalism is an infantile disease. It is the measles of mankind."~ Albert Einstein

An American patriot is rumored to have once said, "My country, right or wrong, I stand by it." 
While it is arguably a very noble trait to stand up for and support your own country, is deriding another country the way to go about doing it? Was Patriotism really meant to be what we see nowadays? Or has it now been converted into a twisted self-centered propaganda mechanism? Is Nationalism merely is a belief, creed or political ideology that involves an individual identifying with, or becoming attached to, one's nation? Or is it an extreme form of patriotism marked by a feeling of unjustified superiority over other countries?
In the current modern World, Patriotism to the masses is about supporting their country, even when the country is in the wrong. It is about abusing and their "enemies", even when they are suffering. It is about considering themselves morally superior. Why? Just cause it is THEIR country.

The current scenario in Syria provides a proper example. The continuous US-led bombing has killed hundreds of innocents, who were already suffering at the hands of the ISIS. The beautiful and ancient cities have been reduced to rubble. And yet major public opinion in the US is with the Government carrying out more air strikes.   Why? Cause the Government considers the Syrian Government and ISIS as enemies and it is the duty of US citizens to support their Governments wars against the enemies. Innocent lives are merely collateral damage for them. Very often while fighting against something wrong, unknowingly we become what we were fighting against. In India, has Patriotism been reduced to merely supporting our Cricket team during the World Cup and insulting countries like Pakistan and Bangladesh whenever we get a chance?
For an Indian to be patriotic, does he really need to abuse Pakistan and hate Pakistanis? Do we really need to treat people Bangladesh, Nepal, and Bhutan as if they are below us? The moment we say that we are better than them cause this is my country and I will support it to the death, we are throwing logic and reasoning out of the window. And that is the first step to extremism. History is the proof that whenever someone considered their country superior than the others around them, it did not end well for the entire world. Be it Hitler, Napoleon or the English East India Company.
I know a lot of those reading this will argue that all other countries are guilty of doing the same, and they are right! Every country does this while preaching of world peace on the other hand. For the world to be at Peace no country should consider itself morally superior, cause we are all suffering together.
The reason there is so much hatred in our sub-continent is that from the very young age children in India are told that we are better than Pakistan. Similarly, children in Pakistan are manipulated the same way. They are taught to blame India for every minor fault. We are taught to ridicule them and taunt them for everything. In general opinion of India, Pakistan is a barren wasteland of people who only worship God and get trained as a terrorist. Similarly, people in Pakistan might consider India as a bully big brother which wants it destroyed. What either side keep forgetting is that both Pakistan and India are a beautiful part of the very same land. It was all part of the same country once, and the very same world. We ridicule Bangladesh when immigrants cross over to India and refer to them as refugees and consider them as people living on India's mercy. We criticize Sri Lanka, even when Indian fishermen get caught after violating International Maritime Laws. Why? Just cause we should support our country, even when they are wrong?  What we do not understand, is for one to be a proud Indian, hating Pakistan is NOT an essential criterion. Just as to be a proud Hindu, you need NOT hate Muslims or Christians and vice versa.  You can love your country. Doesn't mean you have to hate others.


There is also a huge difference in being an anti-national and ant-Government. Everyone who speaks out against the Government is NOT a terrorist. History is proof that those who oppose their Governments may also be the true patriots. It is the duty of a real patriot, to not only love its country but to also stand up and speak when its Country is doing something wrong.
Extremist Patriotism is to blame behind all hindered peace processes. It is our belief that by insulting and abusing another country, we are actually showing our Patriotism. That does NOT show our Patriotism. It merely incites hatred towards the other Countries and encourages an irrational sense of superiority.  Only through honest dialogue can peace be achieved.


I am not against being proud of our culture and heritage and rich history. I am against anyone considering that their culture and heritage is better than someone else's.





A major problem with India-Pakistan relations has always been the fact that both sides care too much about what was their past and too little about what we can achieve together in the future. 

Wednesday, 22 April 2015

Dialogue as a Key Driver of Peace

One of the key drivers of peace is DIALOGUE. So, what is a dialogue? Of course, etymologically, dialogue can be in contrast against monologue, which a one-way of communication. Thus, 'dialogue' can be defined as a two-way of communication of two more parties, in which listening and speaking or receiving and giving activities are well-balancedly put. Furthermore, it implies other qualities such as equality, understanding, empathy, patience, etc.
Let's see a more sophisticated and enlightening definitions by some experts.

“A dialogue is very important. It is a form of communication in which question and answer continue till a question is left without an answer. Thus the question is suspended between the two persons involved in this answer and question. It is like a bud with untouched blossoms . . . If the question is left totally untouched by thought, it then has its own answer because the questioner and answerer, as persons, have disappeared. This is a form of dialogue in which investigation reaches a certain point of intensity and depth, which then has a quality that thought can never reach.”
- Jiddu Krishnamurti

"Critical and liberating dialogue, which presupposes action, must be carried on with the oppressed at whatever the stage of their struggle for liberation." - Paulo Freire

“No peace among the nations
without peace among the religions.

No peace among the religions
without dialogue between the religions

No dialogue between the religions
without investigation of the foundation of the religions.”
- Hans Küng

“Our ability to offer empathy can allow us to stay vulnerable, defuse potential violence, help us hear the word 'no' without taking it as a rejection, revive lifeless conversation, and even hear the feelings and needs expressed through silence.” - Marshall B. Rosenberg

Those are some of my favorite quotes on dialogue. From a more contemporary figures, the quotes are also very interesting.

“I watch silent movies on mute. But only for the dialogue.”
- Jarod Kintz, A Zebra is the Piano of the Animal Kingdom

“Perception can be one-sided or variant: "Glass half empty or half full." There usually is more than one way of perceiving. Thoroughly check your inner dialogue.”
- T.F. Hodge, From Within I Rise: Spiritual Triumph Over Death and Conscious Encounters with "The Divine Presence"

Dialogue itself is a the heart of my work, related to build peace, transform conflict and establish a sustainable intercultural & interfaith dialogue. Then, how dialogue can be achieved through my work. While dialogue itself can be perceived as a goal, it is also a tool to reach a bigger mission. Some qualities of a (good) dialogue, mentioned above, definitely the prerequisites needed. Equality, understanding, empathy, patience, compassion, honesty, and openness are some of those. Indeed, there are also some more technical qualities, such as active listening skills. However, I believe a dialogue does not only a conversation with others. Rather than that, a dialogue is a more continuous conversation with one self. The question, then, do we have a dialogue with our inner self?
Share your own story (OR) share an inspirational person’s story that has changed your way of thinking or has inspired you.

Tuesday, 21 April 2015

Actionable Empathy

Week Two of the Building Peace Project saw the Team Hope having candid yet heartwarming discussions about Peace and what it means to us, both on a micro and macro level. Kirthi Di also had us discussing the key drivers of Peace, namely Empathy, Mutual Respect, Gender Equality, Religious Tolerance and International Cooperation. She encouraged us to ruminate about the same and jot down how any one particular driver of Peace can be developed in the course of our work.

Only trouble is, my daily college classes just got over and the exams are still a month away. So the only work I seem to be doing these days, is trying to catch up with my never ending To Read list.

So when I sat down to write this blog post, my thoughts kept bouncing back and forth between the story that I had read and the concept of Empathy. And as far as I can tell, those two have a lot to do with each other.

Reading a book is like going down the Rabbit hole to Wonderland. It takes you places you never thought you could go to. It puts you in situations that you might never get to face in real time. It leads to all sorts of wonderful chemical reactions in your head. Especially if you're reading fiction, it leads you to meet characters sometimes as complex as the people we meet in life. 

When we read about these characters, we understand things from their point of view. For a little while you forget yourself and immerse yourself in another one's reality. We step into their shoes and view the world through their glasses and that is all needed for Empathy to take root. 

Some studies conducted recently well document this quite well. Reading is directly related to emotional intelligence of which Empathy forms a major part. I read about two such studies here and here.

Which brings me effectively to my point. Empathy, as well as many other Psychological phenomena, are often stereotyped as not being actionable. When in reality, something as common as reading can help in developing Empathy, which in turn leads to Peace.

Which is why, I have listed Empathy as the very first of the key drivers of peace. It starts with oneself. Then, when another person is introduced to this mix, you get a  'self' and an 'other' and Mutual Respect will evolve from mutual empathy. When a gender difference is calculated in, only mutually empathetic and respectful individuals can find themselves as equals. With religion tolerance and international cooperation, this circle of peace widens. I have imagined it to look something like this.


I am a psychology student. In non technical terms, as future Counselors, our work will involve helping people achieve intrapersonal and interpersonal peace and growth. To be able to do this successfully, counselors build what is known as a therapeutic alliance with subjects. This is the creation of a judgment free zone where the subject and the counselor work to alleviate specific problems. This in turn required the Counselor to demonstrate three important qualities towards the subject. They are Empathy, Authenticity and Positive Regard for each other. Then and only then can the process of peace building be started.